I was recently thinking about the ways in which some enterprise 2.0 and social media evangelists proclaim that because many people have just installed a wiki or a blog, and suddenly got traction with building relationships, collaboration and interaction, that all you need is to “just do it” and throw in some web 2.0 technology in order to have success.
I was thinking about this at 3am one morning and it made me think of scissors … yes, scissors.
I could give scissors to someone as a gift and know that they’ll use it for cutting things because, everyone needs a good pair of scissors at some time or other. But people need different sorts of scissors for different things. A good pair of shears is just invaluable in the kitchen — I don’t ever think I could do without my Mundial shears! I also have a big pair of dress making scissors — you know the ones with stainless steel blades and big black handles (I think I ‘inherited’ them from my mother). They’re great for cutting fabric without the blades quickly going blunt. I also use these to cut my dog’s fur when it gets long, but I’d rather have another pair just for that task. I also once gave a pair of round-nosed scissors to my nephew, who loves to draw and cut out paper, but I know he’ll never be able to use it for cardboard — it’s just too thick to cut!
In the end, there are lots of different types of scissors. You can buy generic ones and know they might do many jobs, but they won’t do all cuttings jobs. You could try and use them for anything but you might end up breaking them. Essentially, the only way to know what sorts of scissors to buy for yourself, or someone else, is to know what scissors they already have, and what scissors they might use for specific circumstances defined by need.
There are also lots of different types of social media you can choose from for use within the enterprise for collaboration or outside for communication and interaction with stakeholders. Most of these are as easy to start using as picking up a pair of scissors from Walmart or Target. And like scissors, these social media tools are now both easy to use and sophisticated enough to support real social behaviour, it’s more than likely that they will be successful in some way or other. But when you install a wiki or a blog how do you know whether it will be successful? Just because someone else’s technology implementation went well, do you know whether it will work for you? Sure, everyone in an organisation needs to share information, collaborate and communicate at some time. People need these tools just as much as they need a phone, a pen, and a pair of scissors. But, at the end of the day, how will you know the factors that contributed to their success so you can repeat the success at a later time? How will you know whether they have given you any actual return on your investment?
Last time I went into King of Knives to talk about scissors I got asked the following questions. Strangely enough, I think they’re also a good guide for thinking about social media:
- Who is it for? Do you know the who will use it, their wants and needs?
- What will they use it for: What on earth will they actually use it for? If they have had ones in the past, what did they have? Did it work properly? Will past user’ experience benefit this time around or hamper your efforts?
- Will they know how to do maintenance on it? Scissors need sharpening from time to time. I had to learn how to use a sharpening stone to get the best out of my kitchen shears. Social media tools also need attention — you can’t just build it and expect it to be largely self-maintaining. You need to know how to use these tools to know how to effectively establish and maintain online relationships and build trust.
- Will they need training or is it fairly intuitive? Knowing how to make best use of the tools you have means you get the best return on investment. Training is good, but remember that it won’t change people’s behaviour. Even though you might give people the skills and capability it doesn’t mean that people will use the things you give them.
I know it’s a pretty strange metaphor, but it works. Cut away with your scissors, they might work or they might not, but the only way to know whether or not you’ve spent resources in the right place, and can repeat any success (or avoid future failure), is to do planning and ask these question before you make your choice of shears or scissors.
M